Elected Patriarch of Constantinople in 340, Saint Paul was one of the firmest defenders of orthodoxy against Arianism. Persecuted by Emperor Constantius, he endured multiple exiles across the Empire before being deported to Armenia. He died there as a martyr, strangled by his enemies in his dungeon around 350.
Guided reading
7 reading sections
SAINT PAUL, PATRIARCH OF CONSTANTINOPLE,
MARTYR
Youth and election to the patriarchate
Born in Thessalonica, Paul led an irreproachable life before being ordained a priest and then designated as successor by Bishop Alexander of Constantinople in 340.
*Vir justus exilium non timet, sed exilium ibi esse putat, ubi virtuti non sit locus.*
The just man does not fear exile, and he calls no land a place of exile except that where there is no room for virtue. *Cicero, Orat. 26, pro Milone.*
If the Apostle Sai nt P Paul Patriarch of Constantinople and martyr for the defense of the consubstantiality of Christ. aul could justly boast of having been whipped three times for the confession of the name of Jesus Christ, the Paul of whom we speak here can also boast of having suffered slander, persecution, and exile for the defense of the divinity and consubstantiality of the same Jesus Christ with his Father. He was born in Thessalonica, an ancient city of Macedonia, and he spent his youth with honor and in an irreproachable manner; for the Arians, despite all their efforts, could never convict him of any disorder that could tarnish his reputation, as they wished. He entered the clergy of Constantinople and was ordained a priest by t Constantinople City where the saint exercised his ministry and patriarchate. he bishop of that city, Alexander, who designated him, while dying, as his successor (340). There was all the less difficulty in deciding on this election because Paul was very skillful in the art of handling speech, and to great zeal he joined a profound science, which made him the terror of the Arians. These heretics, by dint of slander, had already had him exiled once. Macedonius, who aspired to the see of Consta Macédonius Arian rival of Paul for the see of Constantinople. ntinople, saw in Paul a competitor who had to be supplanted. He attacked him with false accusations, decrying his morals which had always been so pure; but his lies having had no success, he was forced to desist from his criminal enterprise: he even made a show of repentance, and played his role of hypocrite so well that shortly after, Paul raised him to the priesthood.
Arian opposition and the first exile
Eusebius of Nicomedia and the Arians had Paul deposed during a partisan council, forcing him to withdraw to the West to the emperor Constans.
However, Eusebius, one of the principal leaders of the Arians, who, against the provision of the Canons, had been transferred from the see of Berytus to that of Nicomedia, resolved to have himself elevated further to that of Constantinople. He renewed against Paul the accusations of Macedonius, had him deposed in a council composed of Arian bishops or c ourtiers Constance Roman emperor who exiled Eusebius for his opposition to Arianism. of the emperor Constantius, a supporter of Arianism, and obtained being placed on the see of the new Rome in 340. Paul, seeing himself useless to his flock because of the influence of the Arians, whom the emperor Constantius pro tected, Constant Roman Emperor of the West, protector of Saint Paul. withdrew to the West, where Constans reigned. He was received with great marks of respect by both the prince and Saint Maximin of Trier. Having stayed for some time in that city, he went to Rome, where he found Saint Athanasius. There, he attende pape Jules Pope who supported Paul and Athanasius against the Arians. d the council that Pope Julius held in 341. The Fathers of this council assembled in the church where Viton was accustomed to instruct the people and of which, consequently, he was the priest.
The Pope's support and the restoration
Pope Julius I reaffirmed Paul's authority during a synod in Rome in 341, ordering his restoration in the face of Arian claims.
In the synod of which we have just spoken, it was decided that Saint Athanasius, Saint Paul, and Marcellus of Ancyra would be restored to their respective sees. Pope Julius, by virtue of the authority he held in the Church, sent them back with a circular letter addressed to the Eastern bishops, which has been preserved for us by Saint Athanasius. Julius disapproved of the conduct of the Arians, especially in that they had dared to judge the bishops of the principal sees that the Apostles had governed, without having previously written to him, as was the ordinary practice; and he ordered the restoration of the three prelates.
Saint Paul, having returned to Constantinople, could not recover his see until after the death of Eusebius, which occurred in 342. As much as his restoration was pleasing to the Catholics, it was displeasing to the Arians. This is why the latter, who had Theognis of Nicaea and Theodore of Heraclea at their head, chose Macedonius as their bishop. This action was followed by a violent sedition. The whole city ran to arms, and several people lost their lives there.
Persecutions under Emperor Constantius
Emperor Constantius, favorable to the Arians, banished Paul several times despite the support of his brother Constans and the decisions of the councils.
Constantius, who was at that time in Antioch, flew into a rage when he heard this news. He ordered Hermogenes, general of his troops, who was going to Thrace, to pass through Constantinople and drive out the holy bishop. Hermogenes found the city in a strange state of confusion, and the efforts he made to execute the commission with which he was charged only resulted in increasing the unrest and costing him his life. This outrage, committed against the emperor in the person of one of his officers, prompted him to come to Constantinople himself, even though it was the middle of winter; but he allowed himself to be swayed by the prayers of the senate, which was soliciting mercy for the people; however, he took his revenge on Paul by banishing him, even though he refused to confirm the election of Macedonius, because he had been involved in the sedition.
It is not known precisely where the Saint was exiled; it appears that he withdrew once again to Trier. We find him again in Constantinople, where, in 344, he had come with letters of recommendation from the Emperor of the West. Constantius only consented to his reinstatement because he feared bringing the arms of his brother upon himself.
Paul's situation was no more tranquil than before; and the Arians, still in favor, continued to cause him a thousand troubles. He expected some help from the council that was held in Sardica in 347; but things did not change for that reason. The Eusebians, having assembled at Philippopolis, pronounced a sentence of excommunication against Saint Paul and Saint Athanasius, Pope Julius, and several other bishops who, like so many pillars, supported the Catholic faith. The mistreatment suffered by the orthodox increased even more after the death of Constans, which occurred in 350.
Secret arrest and deportation
After the death of Constans, the prefect Philip secretly arrests Paul to avoid a popular revolt and sends him into forced exile toward the borders of Armenia.
Constantius, having nothing more to fear from his brother, declared himself more openly than ever in favor of the heretics. Animated by their discourse, he sent from Antioch, where he was then, an order to Philip, the praetorian prefect, to drive Paul from the Church and the city of Constantinople, and to put Macedonius in his place. The prefect was sold to the Arian party; but he dared not use violence, for fear that the people, filled with affection for their pastor, might revolt; he therefore had it said secretly to Paul to come and meet him at one of the city's baths where he was waiting for him. This was the place he chose to show him the prince's order. The Saint submitted without the slightest resistance, despite the irregularity of his condemnation. However, the people, who suspected some evil design, had gathered at the door of the bath; Philip, to avoid a sedition, had the prelate pass through a door that was on the opposite side, and sent him under guard to the palace, which was not far away. Paul was taken to Thessalonica, without, however, being assigned a place of exile. Thus, he at first had the freedom to remain where he wished: but his enemies soon accused themselves of too much indulgence; they had him loaded with chains and sent to Singara, in Mesopotamia; from there, he was transported to Eme sa, in Cucuse Place of exile and martyrdom of the saint in the Taurus Mountains. Syria, then to Cucusus, a small town situated in the deserts of Mount Taurus, on the borders of Cappadocia and Armenia, where the air was very unhealthy: there he was locked in a dark dungeon and left in total abandonment. His enemies went so far as to forbid anyone from giving him any food.
The martyrdom at Cucusus
Locked in a dungeon at Cucusus and deprived of food, Paul was finally strangled by his enemies in 350 or 351.
Six days later, irritated that he was still alive, they had the barbarity to strangle him; but, to hide their crime, they announced that he had died of illness. His martyrdom occurred in 350 or 351.
As for Philip, he could not escape the blows of divine vengeance: that same year, he was stripped of his dignities as well as his possessions. Having become the plaything of all those who had known him, he seemed to desire, like Cain, that a murderous hand would come to deliver him from his remorse; but he had to expiate his crime in the languor of a long exile, far from his homeland and forgotten by his former friends. Divine justice extended even to his son Simplicius, who was, eight years later, condemned to perpetual exile.
Translation of relics and posterity
His remains were transferred to Constantinople under Theodosius, then to Venice in 1226, becoming a symbol of the victory of Orthodoxy over Arianism.
Saint Paul was no longer alive, the Arians remained masters of the Church of Constantinople, and they held it until 379, the time when Saint Gregory of Nazianzus was elected bishop of that city.
The body of the Saint was carried from Cucusus to Ancyra, in Galatia, where it was surrounded by great veneration. Theodosius had it transferred to Constantinople (June 7, 381). As this was the day after the closing of the council held in that capital under his reign, all the Fathers of the illustrious assembly attended this solemn translation. The precious remains were deposited in the church which had been built by Macedonius and which, since that time, was known only by the name of Saint Paul. Thus, this famous basilica, which the enemy of our Saint had made the citadel of the Arian heresy, became, by the effect of the secret designs of Providence, the imperishable trophy of the Martyr of Orthodoxy.
The relics of the holy bishop of Constantinople were carried to Venice in 1226, and they are ve Venise Final location of the transfer of relics in 1200. nerated there in the church of Saint Lawrence, which belonged to a Benedictine monastery.
He may be represented with a rope or cord around his neck, to recall that he was strangled with his pallium in a chapel where he was celebrating the holy mysteries.
We have drawn this Life from Godescard, Brussels ed., 1854, and we have composed it according to the Acta Sanctorum, vol. II of June. — All the Latin martyrologies make honorable mention of Saint Paul the Patriarch, as does the Greek Menaion, on September 6. His Life was given by Metaphrastes, who collected it from ancient monuments, by Lipounas and by Sories. Saint Anastasius, his contemporary, Socrates, Secundinus and Theodoric describe his actions in quite some detail. Several authors still speak very honorably of him, according to the report of Baronius, as also in Elysium, both in his Ecclesiastical Annals and in his Annotations on the Roman Martyrology.
Annexes & related entities
Structured data for exploration: events, miracles, quotes, places, attributes, patronages, and important entities cited in the text.
Key Events
- Born in Thessaloniki
- Priestly ordination by Bishop Alexander
- Election to the See of Constantinople in 340
- Successive exiles caused by the Arians and Emperor Constantius
- Participation in the Council of Rome in 341
- Restored to his see in 342 and again in 344
- Excommunication by the Eusebians at Philippopolis in 347
- Secret arrest by Prefect Philip
- Exile to Cucusus in the Taurus Mountains
- Martyred by strangulation after six days of forced fasting
Quotes
-
Vir justus exilium non timet, sed exilium ibi esse putat, ubi virtuti non sit locus.
Cicero (as an epigraph to the text)